inklap

Student Misconceptions about Cybersecurity Concepts: Analysis of Think-Aloud Interviews

Julia D Thompson, Geoffrey L Herman, Travis Scheponik, Linda Oliva, Alan Sherman, Ennis Golaszewski · Journal of Cybersecurity Education, Research and Practice · 2018

We conducted an observational study to document student misconceptions about cybersecurity using thematic analysis of 25 think-aloud interviews. By understanding patterns in student misconceptions, we provide a basis for developing rigorous evidence-based recommendations for improving teaching and assessment methods in cybersecurity and inform future research. This study is the first to explore student cognition and reasoning about cybersecurity. We interviewed students from three diverse institutions. During these interviews, students grappled with security scenarios designed to probe their understanding of cybersecurity, especially adversarial thinking. We analyzed student statements using a structured qualitative method, novice-led paired thematic analysis, to document patterns in student misconceptions and problematic reasoning that transcend institutions, scenarios, or demographics. Themes generated from this analysis describe a taxonomy of misconceptions but not their causes or remedies. Four themes emerged: overgeneralizations, conflated concepts, biases, and incorrect assumptions. Together, these themes reveal that students generally failed to grasp the complexity and subtl

📖 افتح في inklap 🔗 DOI 📮 اطلب بحثاً